Completed in 1996, Andy Lewis's MPhil is the result of many years of exploration, research and excavation, producing the most comprehensive study of the mines hitherto undertaken.
|
PREHISTORIC MINING AT THE GREAT ORME Criteria for the identification of early mining C. Andrew Lewis M.Phil University of Wales – Bangor Agricultural and Forest Sciences September 1996
|
SUMMARY
This study describes and discusses the criteria for the identification of prehistoric or early mining on the Great Orme. Particular emphasis is placed on the geological conditions of the ore deposit and how this has governed the scale and morphology of the extensive workings now recognised at the site. This was achieved by underground and surface surveys of the workings together with precise recording of geological formations through the same areas. The principal routes through the 18-19th century workings were surveyed, concentrating on localities where evidence for early phases of mining existed. Geological recording took the form of logging individual rock strata and associated mineralisation from surface exposures to the deepest sections of the mine where early mining could be identified.
The artefacts and features of the prehistoric workings were also investigated, by a review of all existing historical and archaeological documentation relating to the site supplemented by evidence obtained directly through this study. From this it was possible to distinguish differences in mining artefacts and features between the prehistoric period and the 18-19th centuries. Evidence for prehistoric mining from recognised sites throughout the British Isles, Ireland, Europe and the Near East has also been reviewed and comparisons made with similar evidence from the Great Orme mine workings.
The limited evidence for mineral processing and complete lack of evidence for copper smelting on the Great Orme as well as the local area has also been discussed and possible sites for these operations are suggested. It is calculated that quantities of smelted copper metal in excess of 200 tonnes could have been mined from the Great Orme, suggesting this site may have been a significant contributor to metal production during the Bronze Age period in the British Isles.
CONTENTS
2.2 Prehistoric Mining in Europe to Middle East
Bouche Payrol
Cabrieres
Seronais
Rudna Glava
Aibunar
Timna
Northern Oman
2.3 Prehistoric Mining in Great Britain and Ireland
Mount Gabriel
Ross Island
Cwmystwyth - Copa Hill
Nantyreira
Other Mid Wales Sites
Parys Mountain
Alderley Edge
2.5 Historic Background to Mining at the Great Orme
2.6 History of Archaeological Evidence at the Great Orme Mines
2.6.2 Evidence Earlier this Century
2.7 History of Exploration and Recent Study
3.3 General Setting and Structure
3.5 Results and Interpretations
Dolomitisation and Structural Control
Dolomitisation and Lithological Control
Ore Mineralogy
Dolomite- Dolomitised Limestone
Mudstone
3.5.5 Superficial Deposits and Surface Development
4. EVIDENCE FOR PREHISTORIC MINING
4.2 Description of the Mine Workings
Introduction
Opencast
Southern Entrances
Introduction
Form and Extent
Spoil and Associated Deposits
Calcite Speleothems
Introduction
Classification
Distribution and Use
Introduction
Preservation
Species and Anatomical Distribution
Distribution and Classification
General
Analyses
Ffynnon Galchog
Ffynnon Rhufeinig
Ffynnon Gaseg
Ffynnon Tyn-y-pwll
Processing
Smelting
Summary
4.4.5 Estimated Ore and Copper Production
Opencast
Underground Workings
5.2 Sample Material and Radiocarbon Techniques
5.2.2 Results and Interpretations
5.3 Sample Material and Uranium Series Techniques
6. GENERAL SUMMARY - INTERPRETATION
6.2 Summarised Evidence for Early Mining
6.2.1 Literature Review - Evidence for Prehistoric Mining
6.2.3 Evidence for Prehistoric Mining
6.3 Chronological Development of Early Mining
APPENDICES
A - Survey Data
B - Survey Plans 1:500 Scale
C - Description of Locations
LIST OF PLATES
1. Topographic setting of the Great Orme mines.
2. Opencast workings during excavation in 1991.
3. Opencast workings and Great Orme Mines visitor centre.
4. Southern entrances and trench workings during excavation in 1991.
5. Southern entrances, trench workings and tourist walkways in 1996.
7. Soil horizon indicating boundary between recent and older spoil material.
8. Partly oxidised chalcopyrite stringer vein.
9. Malachite infilled joints in dolomite.
10. Prehistoric working at location 7c, north-west corner of opencast.
11. Underground prehistoric working at location 21.
12. Prehistoric working with stone hammer and calcite cemented spoil.
13. Part of large stope at location 18.
14. Cache of stone hammers located in vein E6-7.
16. Selection of prehistoric mining tools.
17. Markings made by bone tools in rotted dolomite.
18. 'Stone lamp' found in mine workings in late 1800's.
19. Earthenware vessel found in workings off Owens shaft.
20. Calcite flowstone covering floor of prehistoric passage.
21. Sequences of dolomitic silts, sands and gravels at Ffynnon Galchog site.
LIST OF FIGURES
1. Prehistoric mines of Europe
2. Prehistoric mines of Great Britain and Ireland
3. Radiocarbon chronology of prehistoric mines of Great Britain and Ireland 24
4. Great Ormes Head and location of mines in the Pyllau valley
5. Mine workings of the Pyllau valley
6. Geology of the Great Ormes Head (after Morton 1898)
7. Geology of Great Ormes Head
8. Underground survey - Level 1
9. Underground survey - Level 2 & 3
10. Underground survey - Level 4
11. Underground survey - Section A & B
12. Lithological succession - Opencast to Large stope
13. Lithological succession - Owens shaft
14. Lithological succession - Roman shaft
15. Geological succession - Section B
16. Lithological succession - Opencast to Roman shaft
17 Geological plan of Pyllau valley
18. Section through Opencast to Large stope
19. Extent of workings in Pyllau valley
20. 3D view of workings around Vivians shaft
21. 3D view of workings to NE of Vivians shaft
22. Section through mineralised fractures
23. Southern entrances and infilled trench veins
27. Diagrammatic view contrasting 18-19th century and prehistoric workings
28. Location of field monuments on the Great Ormes Head
29. Stone objects (after Dutton & Fasham 1994)
30. Stone objects (after Dutton & Fasham 1994)
31. Animal bone objects (after Dutton & Fasham 1994)
32. Copper alloy and animal bone objects (after Dutton & Fasham 1994)
33. Radiocarbon chronology of the Great Orme mines
LIST OF TABLES
1. Summary of radiocarbon dates for the Great Orme mines
2. Trace element analyses of samples from the Great Orme mines
3. Elemental analyses of metal samples from the Great Orme mines
4. Summary of Uranium Series dates for the Great Orme mines
5. Comparisons between Prehistoric and 18-19th Century
6. Comparisons between Prehistoric and 18-19th Century
7. Comparisons between Prehistoric and 18-19th Century
8. Comparisons between Prehistoric and 18-19th Century Evidence-Spoil
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study is the result of several years working both on surface and underground at the Great Orme mines, and could not have been completed without the assistance of the staff of Great Orme Mines Ltd and members of the Great Orme Exploration Society. I would like to give special thanks to David Jenkins for the many days spent underground studying the prehistoric workings, assisting with the survey drawings, and jointly with Frances Lynch for providing helpful comment and encouragement leading to the completion of this work. Thanks also go to Geoff David who kindly commented on this study and whose surveys helped to produce drawings of location 21. Other thanks go to Chris and Nick Jowett and Edric Roberts for their aid with the underground surveys and also Tony Hammond, Frank Jowett, Danny Dutton and Dave Chapman for providing at times much needed comment and inspiration. I must also mention and thank the numerous institutions that have aided research at the Great Orme, including Bangor University, Birmingham University, Bradford University, British Museum, CADW, Early Mining Research Group, Gwynedd Archaeological Trust, Liverpool University, Minorco Mining Ltd., Plas Tan-y-Bwlch Centre, Portsmouth University, Sheffield University and the Smithsonian Institute. Finally I would like to thank Jane my wife for all the encouragement she has provided, so that one day I would complete this present work.
DECLARATION
What then? Shall we sit idly down and say
"The night hath come; it is no longer day"?
The night hath not yet come; we are not quite
Cut off from labour by the failing light;
Something remains for us to do or dare . . .
And as the evening twilight fades away,
The sky is filled with stars, invisible by day.
H.W.Longfellow